Is the Tesla Model S Still Worth It? Every Version & Trim Compared
The original Tesla — still one of the most capable and longest-range EVs available. Here's the complete guide to every Model S variant.
2026 Model S: Current Lineup
| Trim | Range | 0–60 | Top Speed | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Model S Long Range AWD | 405 miles | 3.1 sec | 155 mph | $74,990 |
| Model S Plaid | 396 miles | 1.99 sec | 200 mph | $89,990 |
The key question: Is the $15,000 Plaid premium worth it?
For most buyers, no — the Long Range is already extraordinarily fast (3.1s 0–60 beats most sports cars) and has slightly more range. The Plaid is for buyers who specifically want the 1.99-second sprint and 200 mph top speed.
Most buyers: Long Range
The Long Range is faster than nearly everything on the road and has more range than the Plaid. Save $15,000 unless you specifically want maximum performance.
Model S vs. Model S Plaid: Full Comparison
| Spec | Model S LR AWD | Model S Plaid |
|---|---|---|
| Motors | Dual (front + rear) | Tri-motor (front + 2 rear) |
| Battery | ~100 kWh usable | ~100 kWh usable |
| Range | 405 miles | 396 miles |
| 0–60 mph | 3.1 sec | 1.99 sec |
| Quarter mile | ~11.9 sec | 9.23 sec |
| Top speed | 155 mph | 200 mph |
| Drag Strip Mode | No | Yes |
| Carbon ceramic brakes | Optional | Standard (Track Package) |
| Price | $74,990 | $89,990 |
Comparing Tesla Model S Versions: Which Year to Buy Used?
Model S Generational Overview
- •Air suspension standard
- •17" portrait touchscreen
- •No Autopilot on earliest units (added mid-2014)
- •Battery options 60–90 kWh
- •AP2.0 hardware (later AP2.5)
- •100D and P100D configurations
- •100 kWh battery = 335 mi range
- •HW2.5 or HW3 (retrofit available)
- •Completely redesigned interior
- •Yoke steering wheel option
- •New horizontal 17" screen
- •Updated motor tech for Plaid
2017 Tesla Model S: Buying Guide
The 2017 Model S is one of the best used EV values available today.
What to check on a 2017 Model S:
- ⚠MCU1 vs MCU2: MCU1 has known eMMC storage chip failure issues. Look for vehicles upgraded to MCU2.
- ⚠Battery degradation: Expect 88–93% capacity remaining at typical mileage (80,000–130,000 miles).
- ⚠Autopilot hardware: Should have AP2.0 or AP2.5 — capable of Enhanced Autopilot but not full FSD neural net.
2017 Model S Pricing (Early 2026)
| Configuration | Original Range | Price Range |
|---|---|---|
| 75D (75 kWh, AWD) | ~257 mi original | $22,000–$30,000 |
| 100D (100 kWh, AWD) | ~335 mi original | $28,000–$38,000 |
| P100D (100 kWh, Performance) | ~315 mi original | $32,000–$45,000 |
2019 Tesla Model S: Buying Guide
The 2019 Model S was near the end of the pre-refresh generation — the last few years before the 2021 redesign.
Key advantages of 2019 over 2017:
- ✓HW3 Autopilot computer: Full Self-Driving capable on most 2019 builds
- ✓MCU2 infotainment: Much more reliable than MCU1
- ✓Slightly improved range: From battery management refinements
2019 Model S pricing (early 2026): $28,000–$48,000 depending on configuration and mileage.
Tesla Model S 2027 Facelift Rumors
What's confirmed: Tesla has not announced a Model S exterior refresh for 2026 or 2027. The current exterior design dates from the 2021 refresh.
What's rumored: Fan renderers and automotive journalists have speculated about Cybertruck-influenced front fascia (full-width light bar), updated frunk design, and potential structural changes.
Likelihood: Model S updates happen infrequently — another major exterior change before 2027–2028 seems unlikely.
Is the Tesla Model S Worth It in 2026?
New Model S
- ✓405 miles range — unmatched
- ✓Plaid's 1.99s 0–60 is the fastest
- ✓Best Supercharger network
Best for: Maximum range and flagship performance
Used Pre-Refresh
- ✓2019 LR at $35K = 370+ mi range
- ✓Excellent reliability track record
- ✓Dated but functional interior
Best for: Value seekers who want premium range
Buy Model Y Instead
- ✓$25,000 less (new)
- ✓More practical cargo space
- ✓90% of the ownership experience
Best for: Buyers who don't need flagship sedan
Buying a Model S? Use a Referral Code
Get 3 months of free FSD or $400 off Solar on your Tesla order.
Browse Referral CodesLast updated: March 2026